Skip to content
Biomed Middle East
Menu
  • About
    • Advertising
    • Authors
    • Consultancy
    • Middle East
    • Privacy Policy
    • Terms & Conditions
  • Articles
    • Acceptance Testing of Medical Equipment
    • Assessment of ultrasonographic features of polycystic ovaries
    • Biomedical Management
    • Genome-wide analysis of Histone H3
    • Healthcare scene in Saudi Arabia for next 5 years
    • Soft Skills in Medical Profession
  • Contact us
    • Feedback Survey
    • Submit Press Release
  • Country Profiles
    • Bahrain
      • Hospitals
        • Al kindi Specialised Hospital
        • Al-Basil Eye Clinic
        • Al-Hilal Hospital – BSC (c)
        • ALBA Medical
        • Ambulance Service Emergency
        • American Mission Hospital
        • Awali Hospital
        • Bahrain Al-Shamil Rehabilitation Center
        • Bahrain Defence Force Hospital
        • Bahrain Medical Bulletin
        • Bahrain Medical Facilities
        • Bahrain MOH Hospital
        • Bahrain Specialist Hospital
        • Cosmetic Surgery Clinic
        • Dr. Tariq Hospital
        • Dr.Tariq hospital
        • General hospital in Muharraq
        • Geriatric Hospital
        • Ibn Al-Nafees Hospital
        • International Society of Aesthetic & Plastic Surgery
        • Jidhafs Maternity Hospital
        • Jidhafs Maternity Hospital
        • Joslin Diabetes Center
        • KIMS Bahrain Medical Center WLL
        • Noor Specialist Hospital (NSH)
        • Pharmacies
        • Salmaniya Medical Complex
        • The Gulf Dental Specialty Hospital
        • The Psychiatric Hospital in Bahrain
    • Egypt
      • Companies
      • Hospitals
        • Aboujaoudeh Hospital
    • Healthcare Index Ranking
    • Jordan
      • Eye Specialty Hospital
      • Abdul Hadi Eye Hospital
      • Abdul Hadi Eye Hospital
      • Abi Obaidah Hospital
      • Akilah Hospital
      • Al Rashid Hospital Center
      • Al-Ahli Hospital
      • Al-Amal Maternity Hospital
      • Al-Amal Maternity Hospital
      • Al-Bashir Hospital
      • Al-Essra Hospital
      • Al-Hanan General Hospital
      • Al-Hayat General Hospital
      • Al-Jazeera Hospital
      • Al-Karak Governmental Hospital
      • Al-Khalidi Medical Center
      • Al-Khalidi Medical Center
      • Al-Maqased Hospital
      • Al-Mowasah Hospital
      • Al-Najah Hospital
      • Al-Ramtha Governmental Hospital
      • Companies
      • Hospitals
        • Jordan Hospital
        • Al-Bayader Hospital
        • Al-Hikma Modern Hospital
        • Al-Mafraq Governmental Hospital
        • Al-Mahabba Hospital
        • Al-Qawasmi Hospital
        • Al-Ramtha Hospital
        • Al-Razi New Hospital
        • Al-Rwaished Governmental Hospital
        • Al-Yarmouk Hospital
        • Al-Zarqa Governmental Hospital
        • Amman Hospital
        • Aqaba Modern Hospital
        • Arab Medical & Scientific Alliance
        • Arab Medical & Scientific Alliance
        • Arab Medical Center
        • Companies
        • Consultancy Hospital
        • Dr. Ahmad Al-Hamaideh Hospital
        • Dr. Jameel Toutanji Hospital – Sahab
        • Elite Specialized Hospital
        • Farah Medical Center
        • Greek Catholic Hospital
        • Hiba Hospital – I.V.F. Center
        • Ibn Al-Haitham Hospital
        • Ibn Al-Nafis Hospital
        • Innovative Medical Technologies – IMT
        • International Hospital
        • Irbid Specialized Hospital
        • Islamic Hospital
        • Istiklal Hospital
        • Italian Hospital
        • Jabal Al-Zaitoon Hospital
        • Jabal Amman Meternity Hospital
        • Jerusalem Hospital
        • Jordan Hospital
        • Jordan Red Crescent Hospital
        • Jordan University Hospital
        • Jordan University Hospital
        • Jordanian Royal Medical Services
        • King Abdullah University Hospital
        • King Hussein Cancer Center
        • King Hussein Cancer Centre
        • King Hussein Medical Center
        • LUZMILA HOSPITAL
        • Maan Governmental Hospital
        • Malhas Hospital
        • Marka Islamic Specialty Hospital
        • Martyr Ibrahim Abu Dieh Hospital
        • Medical Vision
        • Muaath Ben Jabal Hospital
        • National Center for Addiction Rehabilitatin
        • National Center for Mintel Health – Fhais Hospital
        • Palestine Hospital
        • Philadelphia Hospital
        • Prince Ali Ben Al-Hussein Military Hospital
        • Prince Faisal Ben Al-Hussein Hospital
        • Prince Faisal Ben Al-Hussein Hospital
        • Prince Hamzeh Hospital
        • Prince Hashem Ben Al-Hussein Military Hospital
        • Prince Hashem Ben Al-Hussein Military Hospital
        • Prince Rashed Ben Al-Hasan Military Hospital
        • Prince Zaid Bin Al-Hussein Hospital
        • Prince Zaid Bin Al-Hussein Hospital
        • Prince Zaid Bin Al-Hussein Hospital
        • Princess Badea Teaching Hospital for Obstetric & Gynaecology
        • Princess Basma Teaching Hospital
        • Princess Rahmeh Teaching Hospital for Children
        • Princess Raya Hospital
        • Qasr Shabeeb Hospital
        • Queen Alia Military Hospital
        • Rosary Hospital
        • Shmiesani Hospital
        • The Arab Potash Co. Hospital
        • The Islamic Hospital
        • The Specialty Hospital
    • Kuwait
    • Lebanon
      • Companies
      • Hospitals
    • Oman
      • Companies
      • Hospitals
    • Qatar
      • Al Ahli Hospital
      • Al Rafa Poly Clinic
      • Al Shefa Polyclinic LLC
      • Al-Emadi Hospital
      • American Hospital
      • College of the North Atlantic-Qatar
      • Companies
      • Companies
      • Hospitals
        • Doha Clinic Hospital
        • Dr Hanadi Jaber – Doha Clinic Hospital
        • El Emadi Medical Center
        • Fathima Healthcare Management Services(UAE)Qatar
        • Hamad Medical Corporation
        • Helen Ziegler & Associates Hospital
        • Plastic Surgicentre
        • Qatar Foundation’s
        • Qatar Medical Centre
        • Sidra Medical & Research Center, Qatar
        • University of Calgary Qatar
        • Weill Cornell Medical College in Qatar
        • Womens Hospital
    • Saudi Arabia
      • Companies
        • Medir Medical Supplies
        • United Medical Industries Co.Ltd.
        • Ahdaf advanced Electronic Equipments Co.
        • Al Amin Medical Instruments Co.-Amico Group
        • Al Dawleiah Cont. Est
        • Al Faisaliah Medical Systems Co. FMS
        • Al Jeel Medical Company
        • AL Kaws Development Technology
        • Al Nashb Trading Est
        • Al Tuwairqi Holding (ATH)
        • Al-Razi Medical Supplies Est.
        • Almashura Health Group
        • DarFad Trading Group
        • ISAM ECONOMIC COMPANY LTD
        • NAFA MEDICAL
        • Samir Photographic Supplies
        • Tamer Group
        • The Saudi Est. for Trading
      • Distributors
        • A W S Distribution
        • Aal Eiwan Medical Co
        • Abdul Mohsen &Abdul Azz Twigry Est
        • Abdul Rahman Al Gosaibi General Trading Co
        • Abdul Rahman Al Qussabi Office
        • Dodhy’s Medical Ltd.
        • Gulf Markets International WLL
        • Yiaco Medical Co. K.S.C.C.
      • Hospitals
        • ABHA PRIVATE HOSPITAL
        • Abu Zinada Hospital
        • Adama Hospital
        • Al Ahli Hospital
        • Al Ameen Hospital
        • Al Barakat Medical Center
        • Al Falah International Hospital
        • Al Hammadi Hospital
        • Al Hamra Hospital
        • Al Jedaani Hospital ( Al Safa )
        • Al Mane General Hospital
        • Al Marghbi Ophthalmology Hosptial
        • Al Mousa Hospital
        • Al Nahda Hospital
        • Al Rafie Hospital
        • Al Safwa Hospital
        • Al Salam International Hospital
        • Al Salama Hospital
        • Al Zahra Hospital
        • Alawi Tunsi Hospital
        • ALJ Rehabilitation Hospital
        • Almana General Hospital
        • Aramco Hospital
        • Armed Force Hospital
        • Astoon Hospital
        • Bugshan General Hospital
        • Bugshan Hospital
        • Cardioworld Center
        • Dar Al Fouad Hospital
        • Dr. Abdul Rahman Al Mishari Hospital
        • Dr. Abdul Rahman Taha Bakhsh Hospital
        • Dr. Fakhry Hospital
        • Dr. Noor Mohd Khan General Hospital
        • Dr. Siddiqa Hospital
        • Dr. Soliman Fakeeh Hospital
        • Elaj
        • Elaj Medical Services Co. Ltd.
        • Gama Dental Center
        • Ghadran General Hospital
        • Ghassan N. Pharaon Hospital
        • Green Crescent Hospital
        • International Medical Center
        • Jeddah National Hospital
        • King Abdul Aziz Hospital
        • King Abdul Aziz University Hospital
        • King Abdul Aziz University Hospital Jeddah
        • King Fahad Armed Forces Hospital
        • King Fahad Hospital
        • King Fahad Hospital
        • King Fahd Hospital Jeddah
        • King Fahd Medical Complex
        • King Faisal Specialist Hospital and Research Centre
        • Magrabi Hospital
        • Magrabi Hospitals & Centers
        • Mohammed Hamad Al Dossary Hospital
        • Mouwasat Hospital
        • National Hospital
        • Obaid Specialized Hospital
        • Prince Fahd Bin Sultan Hospital
        • Qatif Central Hospital
        • Riyadh Care Hospital
        • Riyadh Medical Complex
        • Royal Commission Hospital in Jubail
        • Saad Specialized Hospital
        • Saudi Arabia Medical Device market
        • Saudi German Hospital
        • Saudi German Hospital Group
        • Saudi German Hospitals Group
        • Saudi German Hospitals Group
        • Security Forces Hospital
        • Specialized Medical Center Hospital
        • Specialized Medical Center Hospital
        • Sultan Bin Abdul Aziz Humanitarian City
        • Techno Contracting Company Ltd.
        • University District Hospital
      • Saudi Health Expenditure
      • Saudi Healthcare Report
      • Saudi Healthcare System
      • Saudi Hospital Services
      • Saudi Medical device market
    • Top 10 GDP Countries 2000-2050
    • Top Healthcare Systems in The World
    • United Arab Emirates
      • Companies
      • Hospitals
        • Al Noor Madinat Zayed
        • Aga Khan University Hospital
        • Aga Khan University Hospitals
        • Ahalia Hospital
        • Al Ain Hospital
        • Al Amal Hospital
        • Al Bakr Home Nursing Services
        • Al Baraha Hospital
        • Al Maktoum Hospital
        • Al Noor Hospital
        • Al Noor Hospital – Al Ain Branch
        • Al Noor Hospital Airport Branch
        • Al Noor Hospital Clinics
        • Al Noor Hospital Khalifa Street
        • Al Noor Medical Co
        • Al Noor Mussafah Clinics
        • AL NOOR POLCLINIC
        • Al Rafa Hospital for Maternity & Surgery
        • Al Rafa Hospital for Maternity Surgery LLC
        • Al Reef Int Hospital
        • Al Reef International Hospital
        • Al Salama Hospital
        • Al Wasl Hospital
        • Al Zahra Hospital
        • Al Zahra Hospital
        • Al Zahra Private Hospital
        • Al Zahra Private Hospital
        • Al Zahra Private Medical Centre
        • Belhoul European Hospital LLC
        • Belhoul Int Hospital Centre
        • British Medical Consulting Centre
        • Canadian Specialist Hospital
        • Cedars – Jebel Ali International Hospital
        • CEDARS – Jebel Ali International Hospital
        • Central Private Hospital LLC
        • Central Pvt Hospital (L L C)
        • Cosmesurge & Emirates Hospital
        • Cosmetic surgery Dubai
        • Dar Al Shifaa Hospital
        • Dubai Healthcare City
        • Dubai Hospital
        • Dubai Medical Laboratory
        • Dubai Sky Clinic Dental Center
        • Dubai Surgery
        • Emirates Hospital
        • Emirates Int Hospital
        • Emirates International Hospital
        • Fujairah Hospital
        • G M C Hospital
        • Ghodousi Medical Center
        • Ghodousi Medical Center Deira Branch
        • Ghodousi Medical Center Deira Branch
        • GMC Hospital, Fujairah
        • GMU SIMULATION CENTER
        • Great Ormond Street Hospital for Children NHS Trust
        • Gulf Diagnostic Center WLL
        • Gulf Medical College Hospital
        • Gulf Medical University
        • Gulf Medical University
        • Gulf Speciality Hospital-Dubai
        • Hospital Franco – Emirien
        • International Private Hospital
        • Iranian Hospital
        • Iranian Hospital
        • Jebel Ali Hospital
        • Khalifa Hospital
        • Kuwait Hospital
        • Lifeline Hospital
        • Magrabi Eye Hospitals
        • Magrabi Specialized Hospital
        • Maternity Hospital,Dubai London Clinic
        • Medcare Hospital LLC
        • Medecins Sans Frontieres
        • National Hospital
        • National Hospital LLC
        • National Medical Hospital
        • Neuro Spinal Hospital
        • New Al Qassemi Hospital
        • New Medical Centre
        • New Medical Centre Specialty Hospital
        • NMC Speciality Hospitals
        • NMC Specialty Hospitals
        • NMC Specialty Hospitals
        • Oasis Hospital
        • Ras Al Khaimah Hospital
        • Rashid Hospital
        • Rashid Hospital
        • Red Crescent Society of Islamic Republic of Iran
        • Royal Hospital
        • Russian Medical & Scientific Complex
        • Saudi German Hospitals Group
        • Seamaster Hospitality (L L C)
        • Sharjah Equine Hospital
        • Sheikh Khalifa Medical City
        • Shj Corniche Hospital (L L C)
        • Sina Hospital (pvt)
        • SPECIALIZED MEDICAL CARE HOSPITAL
        • Swiss Hospitality (L L C)
        • Tadawi General Hospital
        • Tawam Hospital
        • The Abu Dhabi Corniche Hospital
        • The American Hospital
        • The Belhoul Specialty Hospital
        • The Canadian Specialist Hospital
        • The City Hospital
        • The Gulf Medical Centre
        • The International Modern Hospital
        • The International Modern Hospital
        • The Royal Hospital
        • VETERINARY HOSPITAL, THE
        • Welcare Hospital
        • Zulekha Hospital LLC
        • Zulekha Hospital LLC
        • Zulekha Pvt Hospital (L L C )
      • Moorfields Eye Hospital Dubai
    • World Life Expactancy Statistics
  • Courses
    • Arabic For Special Purposes: Healthcare Arabic
    • Assertive Behavior
    • Biomedical Courses
    • Course Survey
    • Cultural Awareness in the Gulf
    • Customer Service (General) Course
    • Dealing with Difficult Customers
    • Feeling Confident and Motivated in the Workplace
    • Improve your Closing Ratio
    • Labmed Courses
    • Telephone Etiquette For Healthcare
    • What is Biomed Engineering
  • Downloads
    • Operating Manuals
    • Service Manuals
    • Test Equipment Manuals
  • Our Services
    • Middle East Healthcare Distributors
  • Partners
    • Inaiya
  • Products
  • Resources
    • Biomedical Engineering Professions
    • Useful Links
    • Videos
      • Burns During MRI Examination
      • Clinical Scenarios: Medical Devices (Higher Definition)
      • Health Care Simulation Nursing Instruction
      • Integrating Human Factors Engineering into Medical Devices
      • What are Stem Cells?
Menu

Health Law Faces Threat of Undercut From Courts

Posted on November 27, 2010

As the Obama administration presses ahead with the health care law, officials are bracing for the possibility that a federal judge in Virginia will soon reject its central provision as unconstitutional and, in the worst case for the White House, halt its enforcement until higher courts can rule.

The judge, Henry E. Hudson of Federal District Court in Richmond, has promised to rule by the end of the year on the constitutionality of the law’s requirement that most Americans obtain insurance, which takes effect in 2014.

Although administration officials remain confident that it is constitutionally valid to compel people to obtain health insurance, they also acknowledge that Judge Hudson’s preliminary opinions and comments could presage the first ruling against the law.

“He’s asked a number of questions that express skepticism,” said one administration official who is examining whether a ruling against part of the law would undermine other provisions. “We have been trying to think through that set of questions,” said the official, who insisted on anonymity because he was not authorized to discuss the case freely.

While many newly empowered Republican lawmakers have vowed to repeal the health care law in Congress, a more immediate threat may rest in the federal courts in cases brought by Republican officials in dozens of states. Not only would an adverse ruling confuse Americans and attack the law’s underpinnings, it could frustrate the steps hospitals, insurers and government agencies are taking to carry out the law.

“Any ruling against the act creates another P.R. problem for the Democrats, who need to resell the law to insured Americans,” said Jonathan Oberlander, a University of North Carolina political scientist, who wrote in The New England Journal of Medicine last week that such a ruling “could add to health care reform’s legitimacy problem.”

So far, there has been only one ruling on the merits among nearly two dozen legal challenges to the health care act. Last month, a federal district judge in Michigan upheld the law. But another judge, Roger Vinson of Federal District Court in Pensacola, Fla., has joined Judge Hudson in writing preliminary opinions that seemingly accept key arguments made by state officials challenging the law.

Unlike the judge in Michigan, who was appointed by President Bill Clinton, both Judge Hudson and Judge Vinson were appointed by Republican presidents.

“We are not operating under the assumption that those two judges are inevitably going to rule against us,” the administration official said. “But of course we’re planning for the possibility that judges will reach different conclusions.”

The novel question before the courts is whether the government can require citizens to buy a commercial product like health insurance.

Because the Supreme Court has said the commerce clause of the Constitution allows Congress to regulate “activities that substantially affect interstate commerce,” the judges must decide whether the failure to obtain insurance can be defined as an “activity.”

Lawyers on both sides expect the issue eventually to be decided by the Supreme Court. But the appellate path to that decision could take two years. In the meantime, any district court judge who rules against the law would have to decide whether to block enforcement of one or more of its provisions, potentially creating bureaucratic chaos.

Such a decision would prompt a flurry of appeals, as the Justice Department almost certainly would ask the judge and then the appellate courts to stay, or delay, the injunction pending the outcome of higher court rulings.

Administration officials, as well as some lawyers for the plaintiffs, agree that Judge Hudson seems unlikely, based on his comments from the bench, to enjoin the entire law. The judge volunteered at a hearing last month that his courtroom was “just one brief stop on the way to the Supreme Court.”

If he does not enjoin the law, the immediate impact of a finding against the insurance mandate would be limited because that provision, and others that might fall with it, do not take effect for more than three years.

Virginia’s attorney general, Kenneth T. Cuccinelli II, a Republican who filed the Richmond lawsuit, argues that if Judge Hudson rejects the insurance requirement he should instantly invalidate the entire act on a nationwide basis.

Mr. Cuccinelli and the plaintiffs in the Florida case, who include attorneys general or governors from 20 states, have emphasized that Congressional bill writers did not include a “severability clause” that would explicitly protect other parts of the sprawling law if certain provisions were struck down.

An earlier version of the legislation, which passed the House last November, included severability language. But that clause did not make it into the Senate version, which ultimately became law. A Democratic aide who helped write the bill characterized the omission as an oversight.

Without such language, the Supreme Court, through its prior rulings, essentially requires judges to try to determine whether Congress would have enacted the rest of a law without the unconstitutional provisions.

The Justice Department, which represents the Obama administration, acknowledges that several of the law’s central provisions, like the requirement that insurers cover those with pre-existing conditions, cannot work unless both the healthy and the unhealthy are mandated to have insurance. Otherwise, consumers could simply buy coverage when they needed treatment, causing the insurance market to “implode,” the federal government asserts.

The administration argues that other key provisions do not depend on the insurance mandate. Those provisions include establishing health insurance exchanges, subsidizing premiums through tax credits and expanding Medicaid eligibility, all scheduled for 2014.

Nor, administration officials said, would an adverse ruling necessarily undermine certain insurance regulations that recently took effect, like the requirement that insurers cover children younger than 26 on their parents’ policies.

In a hearing last month, Judge Hudson remarked on the difficulty of determining Congress’s intent regarding a law with hundreds of disparate provisions. “This bill has more moving parts than a Swiss watch,” he said.

Lawyers for Virginia have sought to turn one of the federal government’s arguments on its head. They note that the health law explicitly refers to the insurance requirement as “an essential part” of the act’s regulatory scheme, and that Justice Department lawyers — in pressing their point that the law permissibly regulates commerce — have called it the “linchpin.”

If it is so essential, Virginia’s lawyers have asked, why should a judge believe that Congress intended for the rest of the act to stand without it?

Any illusion that the cases are not highly politicized was lost when Republican leaders raced this month to file friend-of-the-court briefs in Pensacola, and Democrats responded with briefs from state legislators and supportive economists. Among the Republicans intervening in the case are Representative John A. Boehner of Ohio, the future speaker; 32 United States senators; and Gov. Tim Pawlenty of Minnesota, a possible presidential candidate.

A White House official said that in the meantime “the litigation is really not having an impact” on the pace of putting the law into effect: “I talk weekly to officials in states that have sued us, and in states that have not. I cannot tell the difference between them.”

KEVIN SACK and ROBERT PEAR
New York Times

Leave a Reply

You must be logged in to post a comment.

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

  • Consider hormone therapy to improve menopause-related skin changes
  • School intervention teaches anaphylaxis, exacerbation response
  • Playing soccer can present kidney health concerns
  • Inducing torpor could provide brain benefits after stroke
  • FDA to require NAION risk warning for GLP-1 therapies
  • Bahrain
  • Biomed Articles
  • Biomed Company News
  • Care Area
  • diet
  • disease
  • Egypt
  • Events
  • Health Care
  • Healthcare IT
  • Healthcare Middle East
  • Healthcare Reports
  • Imaging
  • Infection Control
  • Innovations & Advances
  • Interviews
  • Jordon
  • Lab Medicine
  • New Devices
  • News
  • obesity
  • Oman
  • Pharmaceuticals
  • Physiotherapy & Rehabilitation
  • Qatar
  • Regional News
  • Saudi Arabia
  • Telemedicine
  • Tenders
  • United Arab Emirates
  • Upcoming Courses
  • weight loss
©2026 Biomed Middle East | Design: Newspaperly WordPress Theme
imunify-bot-check